
A jury will decide whether a former Tesla employee deliberately tracked down and killed his co-worker in the Fremont factory parking lot in 2021, or whether the shooting followed a workplace confrontation that escalated into violence.
Prosecutors and defense attorneys delivered their closing arguments Monday in the murder trial of Anthony Solima, now 34, nearly five years after Lee Brasier was shot in the back of the head and leg outside Tesla's Fremont factory, as Bay Area News Group reports.
Solima has been jailed since his arrest in December 2021 and faces a possible life sentence without parole if convicted of the charges and enhancements sought by the Alameda County District Attorney's Office.
Deputy District Attorney Ted McGarvey told jurors that Solima walked off his shift after a dispute with Brasier, as the two men worked together in a section of the Fremont plant that manufactured sprinkler piping. According to the News Group, Solima then returned to the factory and spent roughly an hour searching the parking lot for him.
McGarvey reportedly argued that the killing was premeditated and that Solima had been lying in wait. Brasier was shot shortly before 2:40 pm, approximately three hours after Solima left work.
“He’s surveilling the victim before he shoots him. He is looking for Lee,” said McGarvey, per the News Group. “He’s targeting him.”
Defense attorney Annie Beles argued that whether or not Solima was the shooter, the prosecution had not established what happened in the minutes before the shooting. She pointed to testimony that Tesla employees regularly worked 10- to 12-hour shifts, meaning Brasier was not expected to leave the factory for several more hours.
The News Group reports that Beles offered another possible explanation, suggesting Solima may have become enraged over stolen tools, after allegedly seeing Brasier loading them into his truck.
She argued that such a confrontation could constitute provocation that would reduce the offense from murder to manslaughter. She also challenged the prosecution's reliance on circumstantial evidence.
“If you don’t know what happened between 2:31 pm and 2:36 pm, that means ‘not guilty,’” Beles told jurors, pointing to a significant gap in the available surveillance footage.
The News Group reports that a power outage had knocked out much of Tesla's factory security system from that morning until about 30 minutes after the shooting. The only functioning factory camera captured Solima's Chevrolet SUV leaving afterward.
McGarvey countered that cellphone records placed Solima at the scene, while surveillance footage from a neighboring business allegedly showed him moving around the parking lot and following Brasier's movements as he drove through the lot on a golf-cart-style buggy. Investigators also recovered what prosecutors believe was the murder weapon, an unserialized AR-15, from Solima's car the following day.
The prosecution also pointed to Solima's reported complaints about Brasier handing him the wrong kind of pipe earlier that day, along with an ominous text he allegedly sent his ex-partner asking her to tell their daughter he loved her, per the News Group.
Solima also reportedly texted a supervisor on the day of the shooting that he had a “new opportunity” and would not be returning to work, after walking off his shift.
McGarvey disputed the defense's suggestion that Brasier had provoked the shooting, telling jurors that an argument at work was no justification for killing someone, according to the News Group. He described Brasier as “totally innocent.”
As SFist reported at the time, the killing made national headlines, in part because Brasier's body was discovered just hours after Tesla CEO Elon Musk was named Time magazine's Person of the Year.
The Fremont facility, which spans 370 acres and employs more than 10,000 people, was also facing multiple employee lawsuits that year. In November 2021, a worker filed suit alleging widespread sexual harassment at the plant. The previous month, a federal jury awarded a former Black Tesla employee $137 million in damages over claims of racial harassment, which was cleared to go to trial earlier this year.
Earlier this year, the California Civil Rights Department sued Tesla over racial discrimination claims at its Fremont factory, which is still ongoing.
Previously: Tesla Employee Allegedly Shot Coworker In Parking Lot Following Argument